One of the latest attempts to boost the body’s defenses against cancer is called adoptive cell transfer, in which patients receive a therapeutic injection of their own immune cells. This therapy, currently tested in early clinical trials for melanoma and neuroblastoma, has its limitations: Removing immune cells from a patient and growing them outside the body for future re-injection is extremely expensive and not always technically feasible.
Weizmann Institute scientists have now tested in mice a new form of adoptive cell transfer, which overcomes these limitations while enhancing the tumor-fighting ability of the transferred cells. The research,
reported recently in
Blood, was performed in the lab of
Prof. Zelig Eshhar of the Institute’s Immunology Department, by graduate student Assaf Marcus and lab technician Tova Waks.
The new approach should be more readily applicable than existing adoptive cell transfer treatments because it relies on a donor pool of immune T cells that can be prepared in advance, rather than on the patient’s own cells. Moreover, using a method pioneered by Prof. Eshhar more than two decades ago, these T cells are outfitted with receptors that specifically seek out and identify the tumor, thereby promoting its destruction.
In the study, the scientists first suppressed the immune system of mice with a relatively mild dose of radiation. They then administered a controlled dose of the modified donor T cells. The mild suppression temporarily prevented the donor T cells from being rejected by the recipient, but it didn’t prevent the cells themselves from attacking the recipient’s body, particularly the tumor. This approach was precisely what rendered the therapy so effective: The delay in the rejection of the donor T cells gave these cells sufficient opportunity to destroy the tumor.
If this method works in humans as well as it did in mice, it could lead to an affordable cell transfer therapy for a wide variety of cancers. Such therapy would rely on an off-the-shelf pool of donor T cells equipped with receptors for zeroing in on different types of cancerous cells.
Update, posted on September 12, 2011
In August 2011, University of Pennsylvania researchers reported in The New England Journal of Medicine that they had successfully used Prof. Zelig Eshhar’s approach in a pilot trial of patients with chronic lymphocytic leukemia. The patients were treated with T bodies – genetically engineered versions of their own T cells. “This study has provided a proof of concept for the potency of our T-body therapy: previously shown to work in mice, it has now proved beneficial in cancer patients,” Prof. Eshhar said. “Within three weeks, the tumors had been blown away, in a way that was much more violent than we ever expected, ” said senior author Carl June, MD, professor of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine in the University of Pennsylvania’s Abramson Cancer Center, who led the work. “It worked much better than we thought it would. ”
Encouraged by this initial success, Dr. June and colleagues plan to apply the method to the treatment of other malignancies, including non-Hodgkin lymphoma, acute lymphocytic leukemia and childhood leukemia that is not alleviated by standard family. They also consider using the T bodies in patients with solid tumors, such as ovarian and pancreatic cancer.
Prof. Zelig Eshhar’s research is supported by the M.D. Moross Institute for Cancer Research; the Kirk Center for Childhood Cancer and Immunological Disorders; the Leona M. and Harry B. Helmsley Charitable Trust 50; and the estate of Raymond Lapon.
Cold War against Cancer
Prof. Lea Eisenbach is a pioneer in the field of cryoimmunotherapy. As its name suggests, this approach combines two forms of treatment: cryosurgery, from the Greek cryo, for “icy cold,” and immunotherapy, which harnesses the tools of the immune system. The combination of these two accepted treatments of cancer results in an innovative approach that has produced promising results in the lab.
Eisenbach, of the Weizmann Institute’s Immunology Department, began to experiment with this method some ten years ago, when a physician interning in her lab suggested they look into a technique known as cryosurgery, which is not really surgery at all. Rather, a tumor is pierced a number of times with a needle previously frozen in liquid nitrogen, and the repeated freezing and thawing causes tumor cells to burst and die. This treatment, used increasingly in the past few decades to eliminate cancerous tumors of the prostate, liver, kidney and other organs, causes less damage to surrounding tissue than regular surgery. Yet another advantage: The destruction of tumor cells triggers inflammation, which activates the immune system, prompting it to fight the cancer. This activation, however, does not necessarily prevent the cancer from spreading to other organs. So the goal of cryoimmunotherapy is to enhance the effectiveness of the immune response in metastasis, when the cancer in on the move.
Several years ago, Eisenbach’s team performed cryosurgery on mice that had cancer metastases in the lungs, after which they injected these mice with dendritic cells – cells that detect infectious organisms, malignancy and other dangers, and activate the immune system accordingly. The mice that received the cellular injections remained disease-free for longer periods and lived longer than those treated with cryosurgery alone. But ultimately, only half of them survived.
In the healthy lymph node, dendritic cells (green) form interconnected networks in which T cells (red) migrate. Image: lab of Dr. Guy Shakhar
Moreover, when the scientists later injected the surviving mice with malignant cells, these cells were eliminated by the immune system, so they produced no tumors. T killer cells and other components of the immune system had evidently retained a memory of their previous antitumor response, protecting the mice against a cancer relapse.
Yeda Research & Development Co., the Weizmann Institute’s technology transfer arm, has filed a patent for the dual immune therapy to accompany cryosurgery. If developed further for use in humans, it may be employed in the future to treat various types of cancer while at the same time preventing metastases.